/, Kevin Paul, MLB, Power Rankings, Writers/The David Price Trade Conundrum, with Latest MLB Power Rankings

The David Price Trade Conundrum, with Latest MLB Power Rankings

By |2018-12-09T14:35:46+00:00July 29th, 2014|7 Comments

To deal or not to deal?

That IS the question for the red-hot Tampa Bay Rays, especially when David Price’s name is mentioned.

At the beginning of July, the move seemed like a no-brainer for a franchise that pinches pennies and is constantly looking for ways to build upon its youthful talent pool.  Dealing away its ace at the trade deadline would easily bring in quite a haul for the future.

Fans of the team hated the idea, but it made a lot of sense for the front office.

Rumors swirled.

Then came the hot streak – as hot as the Florida sun.

The Rays are now 16-5 in July, posting a .762 winning percentage, which is the best mark in baseball.  Sitting at 52-54, Tampa Bay is still fourth place in the AL East, seven games back of the division-leading Orioles, and 4 ½ games back in the Wild Card race.

But the playoffs are now a reachable goal, with 50-plus games remaining in the regular season.

On top of that, Tampa Bay’s offense has played a lot better this month, batting .269 as a team, which is ranked 7th in all of baseball.  The pitching staff has posted a 2.73 ERA, second only to the Mariners.

David Price’s value continues to skyrocket, especially considering that he leads the team in wins (11), qualifying ERA (3.08) and strikeouts (183).  Sixteen of Price’s twenty-two starts have been of the quality variety, and he’s 5-0 in July, posting a 1.36 ERA.

David Price pitches for Tampa Bay Rays

David Price has been mentioned in trade rumors, but KP thinks the Rays should keep him

The rest of the rotation has also pitched well, including Alex Cobb (3-0, 2.59 ERA in four July starts), Jake Odorizzi (4-0, 2.90 in last five starts) and the newly returned Jeremy Hellickson (1.00 ERA in two starts).

Teams will continue calling, and hoping that “the price is right”.  

A lot of them.

Numerous contenders could use more pitching, including the division rival Orioles, Yankees and Blue Jays.  Don’t expect an inner-division trade, however.  The Dodgers could be another option, as L.A. has endless cash and plenty of World Series dreams.  Pittsburgh is another option, along with the Kansas City Royals and Milwaukee Brewers.

But the question remains: Should the Rays still consider moving David Price?

Consider?  Yes.

Move?  No.

The Wild Card is still obtainable, and with a steady manager like Joe Maddon, the Rays should go for it.

Tampa Bay is getting healthier and the offense is coming around.

It also would (and should) take a lot of prospects to even pry Price away, which is something that a lot of teams just aren’t doing these days.  Yes, the A’s did it a few weeks back, but that was a rarity.

Tampa Bay’s schedule is another reason to hang onto Price.

The upcoming week will be a challenge, with the Brewers currently in town, the Angels to follow and a trip to Oakland to cap it off.  Escape that stretch in good shape, and the Rays will have a seven-game road stretch against the lowly Cubs and struggling Rangers.

Heading into the final nine games of the regular season, Tampa Bay faces opponents that could very well be out of playoff contention, specifically the White Sox and Red Sox.  The Rays end the year playing the Indians, a team that is also in the Wild Card mix.

The Rays will also face fellow Wild Card contenders quite frequently, with nine games each against the Yankees and Blue Jays.

Landing David Price would have to take the offer of offers.

Since that’s unlikely, Tampa Bay simply shouldn’t see its biggest piece dealt away during a stretch like this.  That would be like prying away Dave Matthews from the Dave Matthews Band, while the band was on tour.

These Rays continue to play great baseball, and post the second-best gain since the last MLB Power Rankings at The Wife Hates Sports.  Tampa Bay gained 44 ratings points, second to division rival Toronto.  The top five winners since the last edition are:

Toronto Blue Jays: +46 points

Tampa Bay Rays: +44 points

Miami Marlins: +30 points

Washington Nationals: +16 points

Chicago White Sox: +16 points

Elsewhere, the Reds have really struggled, falling nine spots to 20th place in the latest rankings.  Cincinnati headlines this edition’s bottom five:

Cincinnati Reds: -55 points

Minnesota Twins: -31 points

Philadelphia Phillies: -20 points

Houston Astros: -19 points

Boston Red Sox: -17 points

The A’s maintain a large lead, while the Angels and Dodgers battle for second place.  The latest rankings are as follows, highlighting the clubs that had positive or negative jumps:

KP’s MLB Power Rankings: July 29, 2014

Note: Statistics and point totals as of Tuesday July 29, 2014 and do not include tonight’s games

1. Oakland Athletics (188 points) –Previously: #1 (+11) 

2. Los Angeles Angels (136 points) –Previously: #2 (-2)

3. Los Angeles Dodgers (120 points) –Previously: #3 (+3)

4. Washington Nationals (109 points) –Previously: #6 (+16)

5. Detroit Tigers (98 points) –Previously: #4 (-16)

6. Baltimore Orioles (97 points) –Previously: #5 (+1)

7. Milwaukee Brewers (87 points) –Previously: #8 (+11)

8. Toronto Blue Jays (77 points) –Previously: #15 (+46)

9. Atlanta Braves (73 points) –Previously: #10 (+7)

10. Seattle Mariners (72 points) –Previously: #7 (-15)

11. San Francisco Giants (64 points) –Previously: #9 (-4)

12. St. Louis Cardinals (59 points) –Previously: #12 (-4)

13. Pittsburgh Pirates (50 points) –Previously: #14 (+14)

14. Kansas City Royals (48 points) –Previously: #13 (-6)

15. Tampa Bay Rays (45 points) –Previously: #19 (+44)

16. New York Yankees (26 points) –Previously: #18 (+11)

17. Miami Marlins (18 points) –Previously: #21 (+30)

18. Cleveland Indians (18 points) –Previously: #17 (+1)

19. New York Mets (15 points) –Previously: #16 (-13)

20. Cincinnati Reds (11 points) –Previously: #11 (-55)

21. Chicago White Sox (3 points) –Previously: #22 (+16)

22. San Diego Padres (-28 points) –Previously: #25 (+10)

23. Arizona Diamondbacks (-30 points) –Previously: #27 (+9)

24. Boston Red Sox (-31 points) –Previously: #23 (-17)

25. Minnesota Twins (-35 points) –Previously: #20 (-31)

26. Philadelphia Phillies (-46 points) –Previously: #24 (-20)

27. Colorado Rockies (-53 points) –Previously: #26 (-15)

28. Chicago Cubs (-61 points) –Previously: #28 (-16)

29. Texas Rangers (-84 points) –Previously: #30 (-8)

30. Houston Astros (-94 points) –Previously: #29 (-19)

* All stats per MLB.com and ESPN.com

Note: RED = Falling 3+ spots from last week, GREEN = Rising 3+ spots from last week

The Wife Hates Sports’ MLB Power Rankings system has a method to its madness, attempting to be different and not just rank by popularity and record.  It mixes a secret formula of six completely different categories, meshed into a points system.  The categories don’t just include team results regarding record, but how each team has performed recently, as well as incorporating some statistics on both a team’s offense and pitching staff, too.

Be Sociable, Share!

About the Author:

Kevin Paul is the creator of The Wife Hates Sports, a freelance sportswriter, full-time QA manager, part-time craft beer tester and full-time Dad. Oh and yes, it is true, the wife REALLY does HATE sports. Maybe I need to create a support group like the Hair Club for Men, where I'm "not only the President, but a member".


  1. admin August 4, 2014 at 9:24 AM

    I think Myers may have been rushed to the major league level, and wasn’t quite ready for the adjustments to the top level arms. He was hitting pretty well in the minors, but not like Gregory Polanco, and guys like that. Heck, even Polanco has gone through a major slump in Pittsburgh. Some of these younger guys just need time to break out. Each player is different. Maybe Myers will be the same way, but how long can a team like the Rays afford to wait?
    For example, the O’s finally gave in on Jake Arrieta, and dealt him away to the Cubs at the deadline last year… now look at the guy, he’s their ace, since the Samardzija deal.

  2. SportsChump August 2, 2014 at 4:21 AM

    I’ve never been a big fan of Myers. Maybe I’m being to harsh on the guy. He still is just a kid. Or perhaps I’m slightly disillusioned that he came over in the Shields trade. Big Game James was the MAN!

    Myers can barely field. He’s supposed to hit for power but doesn’t.

    I know it hasn’t even been two seasons so perhaps it’s too early to call him a bust. Sure would like to see the guy hit for power and average though.

    As of yet I’m not entirely convinced he can and I’m not the only one in the area who thinks so.

  3. KP July 31, 2014 at 6:55 AM

    What are the locals saying about Wil Myers? Bust to this point? He had some moments last year and of course got hurt this year… though his numbers weren’t top notch when he did go down. Longoria fallen a bit, too, though he doesn’t have a ton of protection in the lineup.

    I would say bats, plural, not bat.

  4. SportsChump July 30, 2014 at 2:08 PM

    What for?

    We haven’t had a bat in years.

  5. KP July 30, 2014 at 7:06 AM

    Oooh, the local dish!
    But are you altogether, oooky?

    I think the streak is the biggest part. This wild card is up for grabs right now, and the Rays are playing better than anyone in baseball. If they were really crazy, the FO would consider adding a bat. Doubt it though.

  6. SportsChump July 30, 2014 at 2:41 AM

    Okay, here’s the local scoop.

    The Rays are shrewd enough (definitely) and care about Price enough (probably) that they’re not going to get rid of him for nothing. They can keep him, try to make a run at the post-season and regardless of whether that happens or not try to move him next year, if they want to. They’re not going to move him just to move him. They want parts and lots of them. And why wouldn’t they expect that? The guy is arguably a top five pitcher in the league.

    That’s why, whereas I once thought he was as good as gone, after their recent hot streak, I think he stays.

    Call me kooky.

  7. admin July 29, 2014 at 9:31 PM

    To make the postseason? Yeah, why shouldn’t I believe that? It’s all about pitching, and the Rays have talented young pitching. If they can keep Price, they would have him, along with a number of other solid arms. The Angels are running away with the first wild card spot, but who else does TB have to fight with? Toronto, New York, Kansas City, Seattle and Cleveland… all of which have flaws and are beatable.

Comments are closed.