/, NCAA FB, NFL, Writers/Bill O’Brien Reportedly to Coach Penn State: Weighing the Good with the Bad Regarding the Hire

Bill O’Brien Reportedly to Coach Penn State: Weighing the Good with the Bad Regarding the Hire

By |2018-11-19T17:39:09+00:00January 6th, 2012|4 Comments

Multiple sources are reporting that after months of searching, Penn State has finally come to a decision on its next football coach, reaching an agreement with Bill O’Brien, Offensive Coordinator for the New England Patriots.

As reported by Chris Mortensen of ESPN, an official announcement is expected on Saturday.

The hiring certainly doesn’t answer every last question surrounding Penn State football, but it is yet another step towards a clearer picture of the program’s future.


Sources say Bill O’Brien will be the next head coach at Penn State

While the Board of Trustees has apparently reached its decision, the fanbase is sure to have its share of opinions regarding the hire.  With every decision, there is good and bad.  Take the following points likely to be raised regarding O’Brien, first starting with the negative criticism:

“The Bad”

1) It’s not a sexy hire.

Bill O’Brien has a significant amount of experience in both college and the pros, but he’s likely not a name that anyone had heard of until a few weeks ago.  It’s also likely that most fans would not have been satisfied unless a marquee name like Nick Saban or Chris Petersen came onboard to save the Nittany Lions.

2) Belichick assistants have struggled away from New England.

“Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me.”  While it’s not fair to mesh one individual in with a group of others, it’s hard to ignore the facts.  A number of coaches have struggled upon leaving Belichick’s nest, including Charlie Weis, Eric Mangini and Romeo Crennel.

3) His personality will not fit Penn State.

How did most people first find out about Bill O’Brien?  It’s simple, when he hit the news headlines while having a verbal brawl with Tom Brady on the sidelines during a Patriots game this season.  In that moment, O’Brien came off as a hothead and not someone that many people would want to have roaming the sidelines at Penn State.  It is, however, important to note that in an ESPN video interview, Chris Mortensen squashed the idea, saying that O’Brien is a “smart, even-keeled guy”.

4) How will he handle recruiting?

A close friend’s first criticism was that O’Brien has “no proven track record, especially with recruiting”.  It’s possible that he may be right, but we can’t be so sure of that, at least, not without doing a lot of research.  O’Brien does have experience in the college ranks, which will be addressed in the next section.  Still, it’s a legitimate concern.

5) How will the current players react, and will anyone leave?

Many fans are on board with a fresh start, stating that the removal of the entire current staff seemed like the best move for the university.  However, upon adding O’Brien to the mix, how will the players react?  Will any key contributors decide to transfer?  In addition, will any of the current recruits decide to sign elsewhere when National Signing Day arrives?  How about alums since he’s not a part of the Penn State family?

“The Good”

1) He’s young, provides a fresh face and a fresh start.

O’Brien is just 42 years of age, and provides a much needed fresh start to a program that clearly needed a change.  He’s more than half the age of previous head coach Joe Paterno.

2) His experience is plentiful.

Bill O’Brien doesn’t lack in experience, even though none of it is as a head coach.  Dating back to 1993, O’Brien has been a coach at Brown, Georgia Tech, Duke, Maryland and with the NFL’s New England Patriots.  On top of the experience, he’s said to have a high level of integrity, which is exactly what Penn State was seeking.

3) He’s coached Tom Brady, a future NFL Hall of Famer.

Never understimate the exposure and experience that a coach has had, especially when you’re working and recruiting high school kids.  So many of these young kids grew up watching Tom Brady dominate the NFL.  You don’t think that as a head coach, Bill O’Brien couldn’t use that to his advantage, especially with offensive players, and specifically with quarterbacks?  Penn State hasn’t had a successful pure pocket passer since 1994, when Kerry Collins graduated.


The fact that Bill O’Brien and Tom Brady have worked together will likely be attractive to future recruits

4) He can add an NFL spin to a “vanilla” offense

Aside from the “Spread HD” concept and some recent wrinkles with the Wildcat, the Penn State offense has mostly been “vanilla” for decades.  The lack of creativity had led to nothing but predictability for opposing teams.  It also results in many recruits choosing other destinations, especially ones that run pro-style offenses.  With O’Brien on board, Penn State could dabble in that department, too.

5) Keeping recruits such as Skyler Mornhinweg

With O’Brien’s NFL experience with quarterbacks, it’s possible that he could keep recruits, specifically a kid like Skyler Mornhinweg, whose father is NFL assistant coach Marty Mornhinweg.  The possibility of keeping a highly talented recruit such as Mornhinweg may just rise, but that also remains to be seen.  Still, with the struggles of Rob Bolden and Matt McGloin in 2011, the quarterback position is a definite need for Penn State

In Conclusion

The points highlighted in RED are the ones that strike closest with me regarding the O’Brien decision.  The lack of a sexy hire – while inevitable – presents itself as a disappointment, albeit not at all surprising, especially considering Penn State’s current condition.  Also, the lack of success among Belichick assistants is an even bigger concern.

On the positive side, O’Brien has a track record that branches across numerous college programs, as well as with easily the most successful NFL franchise over the last decade.  New England’s offensive success is no secret in the NFL today, and O’Brien has had a hand in that, while also working with a Hall of Fame NFL quarterback in Tom Brady.  That kind of innovative style and experience could be just what Penn State needs for its offense.  More importantly, having a coach that has worked closely with Tom Brady could help in landing highly rated recruits, such as a kid like Skyler Mornhinweg, who has already given a verbal commitment to Penn State.  Keeping him around would be a big accomplishment for a team that desperately needs stability at the quarterback position.

Penn State football has a long way to go, and many questions remain, such as how the entire coaching staff will look by the time the season starts.

But here’s an opportunity for new beginnings, a fresh face and more healing.

For Bill O’Brien, it’s a huge challenge and an even bigger opportunity.

Be Sociable, Share!

About the Author:


  1. admin January 6, 2012 at 2:05 PM


    Yes, you bring up Clark and Robinson… which is why I listed Collins as the pure pocket passer, and the only time it ever worked, is when PSU used the ‘vanilla’ offense, but had a QB that could make plays with his feet, too. It also worked from time to time with Rashard Casey, just he was much more careless and was surrounded by less talent.

  2. admin January 6, 2012 at 2:03 PM


    Interesting that you bring up Bradley staying on as DC. I was thinking the same thing last night. I have a hard time imagining that the BOT will allow that to happen though, in fear of getting more flack for keeping any current staff on board. In the times that I interviewed Bradley and covered the team, he was a class act to me, and I had great respect for him. It’s a shame it all had to happen this way for him, because he loves PSU.

    That is – and has always been – how Brady reacts on the sideline, but as you say, notice that not one person ever delivered it as Brady’s fault, but only O’Brien’s?

  3. JW January 6, 2012 at 12:47 PM

    The Bad:

    1) “It’s not a sexy hire.” Good, we were never going to get that anyway.

    2) “Belichick assistants have struggled away from New England.” So what? We need a guy willing to wade into the toxic soup this program is now. Belichickian or not, there’s no blueprint for this.

    3) “His personality will not fit Penn State.” Perfect, it shouldn’t. If it takes a village to raise a child, then it took a university to create a child-raping monster.

    4) “How will he handle recruiting?” Who knows? We will all need to sit back and see. Again, there’s no blueprint for how you rebuild such a shattered image.

    5) “How will the current players react, and will anyone leave?” Screw it. If anybody wants out, let them go. Penn State football existed before Paterno, and it will continue after Paterno. Will there a painful rebuilding period? Of course. But real fans had to know that while this was not the end we expected, it’s not like Joe was going to live forever. As for the alums, don’t forget that “family mentality” helped get us into this mess.

    The Good:

    1) “He’s young, provides a fresh face and a fresh start.” Where else is that more needed than in State College?

    2) “His experience is plentiful.” Experience in this case means nothing unless he’s rebuilt another storied program destroyed by a hideous scandal. Again, there’s no blueprint for this.

    3) “He’s coached Tom Brady, a future NFL Hall of Famer.” Not only did he have the stones to call out a future HOFer, but his NFL cred likely helps #5.

    4) “He can add an NFL spin to a “vanilla” offense.” Wasn’t that Galen Hall’s reason for existing? Seems to me that only worked in the Michael Robinson era, with brief glimpses during the Darryl Clark years.

    5) “Keeping recruits such as Skyler Mornhinweg.” The big test will be what kind of recruits O’Brien can get four years from now?

  4. Jared January 6, 2012 at 12:06 PM

    All good points. I am actually in favor of this hire. While LaVar Arrington, Brandon Short, and many lettermen are really upset about a non-Penn Stater as head coach, I think the change will be good.

    I thought about all the things you put here. Of course he can use Brady and the Patriots offense as a recruiting tool. I am really hoping it allows PSU to recruit an NFL-caliber QB. I am sick of Jay Paterno not being able to recruit or develop a passer. Maybe some tall, fast tight ends will be recruited to tear up opposing defenses 🙂

    I would love to see Tom Bradley stay on as defensive coordinator. That is something we are really good at and I hope doesn’t change but I understand O’Brien will want his own staff.

    I am so sick of the media hyping the argument with Brady. Everyone, including the GameDay staff, use that against O’Brien. I respect him more because he is willing to stand up to Brady, who is on a huge pedestal. I like the passion.

    As a Patriots fan, I am sad to see him go but also anxious because it may mean more Nittany Lions filter into New England! We need linebackers, def backs, and linemen…

Comments are closed.