/, PGA, Writers/Rory McIlroy’s Historic Win Should Generate Present Day Arnie and Jack Rivalry with Tiger Woods

Rory McIlroy’s Historic Win Should Generate Present Day Arnie and Jack Rivalry with Tiger Woods

By |2018-11-11T19:46:44+00:00June 20th, 2011|10 Comments

With his scruffy hair and baby face, Rory McIlroy looks more a skateboarding kid nephew than a professional golfer.

But at the 2011 U.S. Open, McIlroy instead looked like a man among boys, torching Congressional Country Club with a 16-under 268, tying or breaking 12 records in the process.

The nearly flawless performance by the 22-year old from Northern Ireland sent the golf world into a frenzy, raising so many questions that even Dr. Phil would get a headache.


One of Many?: Rory McIlroy shows off his prize after dominating the 2011 US Open at Congressional Country Club – his first major win (Image Credit: GolfChannel.com)

And it all happened amidst questions of what would be in a tournament that didn’t even see Tiger Woods set foot on the grounds due to injury.

Now that the dust is settling, where does this leave the golf world?

Have we finally found someone to go head-to-head with Tiger, when others in the past – David Duval being the prime example – couldn’t?  Is McIlroy primed to be the next Tiger, leaving Woods in the dust?  Does Tiger still have a chance to eclipse Jack Nicklaus’ major championship record?  Or do we perhaps have a future where McIlroy himself could eventually threaten that record?

All are questions that could be argued, especially after the wire-to-wire clinic that Rory put on during the four-day span at Congressional.

But the most logical result – which hasn’t been mentioned to this point – is simply this: We are likely to be witnessing the birth of a modern day Jack and Arnie rivalry.

Before you dismiss it, look at some of the similarities that exist.

But first, let’s take a look at Tiger.  Woods may be battling injuries at the current time, but he’s only 35-years old and has plenty of golf left in him.  Jack Nicklaus won 3 major championships in his 40’s, including the ’86 Masters at age 46.

One shouldn’t look at Tiger’s current mental makeup either.  It’s clear enough that Tiger didn’t have a care about personal situations in the past, nor did he have a care about personalities on the golf course.  The one main goal has always been the major championship record, and injuries are the only thing getting in his way.

Well, that is until Rory burst onto the scene.

McIlroy clearly dominated this year’s U.S. Open, winning by eight shots and shattering numerous records.  He also dominated The Masters until the final nine, where it all fell apart.  But don’t look at Augusta as one choke, followed by one other solid performance.  McIlroy clearly learned his major lesson, but most notably, has been right there in the past.  Just look at his best finishes in the four major tournaments: The Masters (tied for 15th, but dominated ‘til the final 9), U.S. Open (won this year at Congressional), British Open (tied for 3rd in 2010) and the PGA Championship (tied for 3rd in both 2009 and 2010).


At age 22, the sweet swinging McIlroy has already been a contender in all four major championships

Finishes like that in all four majors by age 22 prove that McIlroy is no fluke.

Rory has been right there on numerous occasions.  We just never truly noticed until he put on a Tiger-like show – and that’s where the Arnie and Jack comparisons begin.

The following that Tiger built for years closely resembles that of how “Arnie’s Army” was many years ago.  McIlroy has already built a following of his own, flashing smiles while attacking pins on the course, all the while leaving fans chanting “Rory, Rory, Rory” on every hole at the Open.

Arnold Palmer – now 81-years of age, won his first of seven majors in 1958.  Jack Nicklaus, ten years younger, crashed the party in 1962 by winning the U.S. Open (his first major victory) at the age of 22.  Palmer was 32 that year.

Tiger Woods, currently 35, won his first of 14 majors in 1997, which many will recall was his dominant performance at The Masters.  Similar to Nicklaus, McIlroy crashes onto the scene winning the U.S. Open at the age of 22, also just over a decade younger.


KP thinks we haven’t seen the last of Tiger Woods

The timing is one comparison, but the other is Woods himself.  Too many people are discounting Tiger Woods and saying his career is over.  That kind of competitive fire is not a switch that you just turn off.  Woods likely reached his boiling point watching Rory torch many of his major championship records over the weekend.

Mark my words – Tiger will be back – and sooner rather than later.  The only way he doesn’t top Jack Nicklaus’ major championship record will have nothing to do with him or his mental game.  Instead, it’ll be the new wave of competition in the world of golf, headlined by McIlroy.

For those that thought the PGA was ready to hit a downturn, think again.  There is likely to be a resurgence coming.  All signs point to a reincarnation of Nicklaus and Palmer, only in the form of Rory McIlroy and Tiger Woods.

The only question remains: Will the biggest roar come from Rory, or from a rejuvenated Tiger?  Or perhaps someone else crashes the party altogether?

Hide your flagsticks… golf isn’t fading – it’s just gettin’ good.

Who Will Finish With MORE Major Championship Victories?

  • Jack Nicklaus (60%, 6 Votes)
  • Tiger Woods (40%, 4 Votes)
  • Rory McIlroy (0%, 0 Votes)

Total Voters: 10

Loading ... Loading ...
Be Sociable, Share!

About the Author:


  1. admin June 24, 2011 at 7:56 AM


    18, not bad, my friend. I was just curious… because I wanted to gauge how much conversation we could have on it, and if which angle you would take, because as I said, some people that have never touched the game don’t understand how difficult it is.

    I see what you’re saying and agree that it certainly appears that we are seeing a major shift towards Europe for power in golf right now. Hopefully some new Americans step it up on a consistent basis, at least for the sake of the Ryder Cup.

  2. tophatal June 22, 2011 at 10:05 AM

    Played moons ago ….. eighteen handicapper after I got out of the military . It was a way of meeting up with clients and getting business done when I worked in investment banking as an analyst . Now you’re more inclined to find me in a martial arts dojo as the MMA and the martial arts (karate & tae kwondo) are my real passion .

    There are far better up and coming players on the European Tour that show just as much poise as McIlroy and they play a hell of a lot better than most of the younger US players on the PGA Tour in that respect . See in particular Kaymer of Germany and Matteo Mannassero of Italy (who’s only 18 years old and already has two wins on the European Tour) against high classed fields at the time .

  3. admin June 21, 2011 at 9:59 PM


    Yeah, we can touch base over email later this week… sounds good. I’m not around for much or all of Saturday, FYI.

  4. admin June 21, 2011 at 9:33 PM


    Well, I wasn’t just focusing on US… but European, too… there are a bunch of young stars that are coming.

    Do you play golf by the way? In my opinion, it’s the toughest game there is and I’ve played my entire life. When you play basketball, you can suck and still make a shot. In golf, if you suck, you can’t.

  5. Chris Humpherys June 21, 2011 at 12:47 PM

    I’m game.

    I’m out of town this week, to return over the weekend.

    I’ll still have access to email if you want to get together a topic list and find a guest to join us.

  6. admin June 21, 2011 at 9:34 AM


    I have to disagree. It is one major that he’s won, but McIlroy’s numbers at age 22 in majors are impressive… 3 ties for 3rd, a win, plus dominating at Augusta until the final nine on the final day. He’s going to be around more, and I think the PGA is getting more exciting, and not just because of Rory, but there are a number of other youngsters that are up and coming…

  7. admin June 21, 2011 at 9:32 AM


    Yep, there are a good handful of guys that are in their 20’s now that I think will be stiffer competition. We can only hope we have a back and forth battle in a major between Tiger and Rory, too. Now that would be fun…

  8. admin June 21, 2011 at 9:30 AM


    I see, so you have something coming out on this. It would also make a really good podcast topic, if we are still doing that…

  9. aero June 21, 2011 at 8:20 AM

    I believe you’re right, Tiger will make a comeback. What is becoming obvious is that it won’t be as easy for him as it has been in the past.

  10. Chris Humpherys June 20, 2011 at 11:50 PM

    Ooooooh, just wait until you read my next post.

Comments are closed.