/, MLB, Writers/Dan Haren Traded to Angels: Why the New York Yankees Drew the Short Straw Again

Dan Haren Traded to Angels: Why the New York Yankees Drew the Short Straw Again

By |2018-11-02T19:21:42+00:00July 25th, 2010|6 Comments

“Breathing first, winning next…”

That was George Steinbrenner’s mantra as owner of the New York Yankees.

Certainly, that concept has translated to the 2010 Yankees, who have posted the best record in baseball to date – leading division rival Tampa Bay by three games heading into Monday.

But the winning isn’t translating across the board entirely.  For years and years, we expected the men in pinstripes to dominate free agency, take over the standings and reel in whatever player they wanted via trade.

Ding ding ding – you are correct!  Something’s missing.

It’s been no secret that over recent weeks, the New York Yankees have been seeking an impact starting pitcher to bolster their already talented rotation.


Cliff Lee – who nearly landed in the Bronx – instead was dealt from Seattle to Texas

Baseball has had its share of aces available throughout the month of July, from Cliff Lee, to Roy Oswalt, to Dan Haren and then some.

Lee was the first to go – dealt away from a struggling Mariners club, to division rival Texas.

The Yankees wanted Lee badly – and nearly had him.  But the trade fell through.

In fact, the deal was so close, that Joel Sherman of the New York Post described the Bronx Bombers as being “on the brink of obtaining Cliff Lee.”

Here’s the tidbit that’s more puzzling: Not only did the Yankees lose out on dealing for Cliff Lee, they lost out to a Texas team that recently filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

But wait, it gets worse.

The New York Yankees moved on with their negotiations, and baseball assumed it would only be a matter of time that they would get their man.

Dan Haren was next.


Dan Haren was traded to the Angels in exchange for Joe Saunders, two prospects and a player to be named

As SI.com’s Jon Heyman reported, the Yankees had significant discussions with Arizona for Haren, with a number of names tossed around.  New York refused to include Joba Chamberlain, but appeared willing to include prospects such as Ivan Nova and Zach McAllister.

Only, the Arizona Diamondbacks didn’t play along.  Earlier today, the D’Backs dealt away their ace to the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim, in exchange for starting pitcher Joe Saunders, two minor league prospects and a player to be named.

That’s strike two.

But there’s something lost in the depths of baseball breaking news on two blockbuster deals for two No. 1 starters.  Specifically, both of these players were traded to American League clubs – and NEITHER of them was the New York Yankees.

Instead, two AL West teams – both who could wind up facing the Yankees in the playoffs.

What in the name of the Yankee Clipper is going on here?

There are a few ways to look at it.  But in general, the Yankees need to change the way they do business.

Money can’t always buy happiness.

Sure, it worked last season – and it’s worked a lot of seasons, but today’s game is changing rapidly.


The Yankees formula worked in 2009, but the game is changing rapidly

Gone are the days that teams will just give away any player.  Here are the times where top prospects are grown internally and kept for years, or dealt for a bevy of young talent.

New York’s farm system is getting to be on the weaker side.  With bargaining chips like Jesus Montero included in rumors, it would only fall farther into the tank.

There lies your real problem.

You see, the Texas Rangers had the top ranked farm system according to ESPN’s Keith Law in 2009 – and that’s the main reason they were able to seal the deal for Lee. 

Plain and simple, there was simply more to offer up.


Joe Saunders is the main piece in the deal that brings Dan Haren from Arizona to Anaheim

Meanwhile, while the Angels rank significantly lower on the list, they have a number of low-to-mid 20-somethings on the roster (that are of high value, too).  That includes the likes of Joe Saunders, who will now be sporting Sedona red, as opposed to Yankee pinstripes.

So that’s the deal – the MLB Draft features a pool of many question marks.  Only a few guys emerge as legit talent.  Sure, home-grown players can grow into contributors.  But over recent seasons, the Yankees have been dealing away the majority of their prospects (for impact players).

For every Joba or Hughes that is still in New York, there are two to three others sent away for a quick fix.

Go ahead and spend all the money on Earth during an offseason.  Once the season begins, a number of issues can arise, from struggles to injuries.  A team will almost always need to dip into the minor league talent pool.  When that pool has no water, well, it’s a little tougher to keep swimming.

In today’s game, teams like the Rangers, Rays and Angels have a significant mixture of free agent and minor league talent.  This makes it easier to put the final pieces into place.

At this rate, the Bronx Bombers are losing that luxury.  Instead, trades for big names are falling through.  The competition is catching up.  The Yankees can just sit and hope that “the best roster money can buy” has what it takes to seal the deal and hoist the trophy.

Breathing may be first – and winning may be next, but baseball now has a new formula for both.

If a franchise can’t adjust – then the result could easily be “strike three.”

Be Sociable, Share!

About the Author:


  1. admin August 2, 2010 at 11:39 AM

    I hear you, man. The thing is: Tampa Bay has the great minor league system built up, so when a guy like Crawford likely moves on, there’s another talented guy ready to replace him. They are in good shape.

    As for the Yanks, well… as I figured, they eventually broke through and found a few big names… this time being Berkman and Wood… though still not Lee or Haren.

    Downstairs Joe—
    I still think you should keep this name… it’s funny.

  2. admin August 2, 2010 at 11:33 AM

    Upstairs Marnie—
    In the end, the Yankees ended up bringing in a few big names anyway… Lance Berkman and Kerry Wood… as usual they’re loaded for the stretch run.

    Chris REV—
    Lackey has had moments where he has struggled, sure… but it’s just one year and if Boston were to make some kind of a run to make the playoffs, we’ll see how Lackey would do there – that could change everything. Boston needs to get healthy.

  3. Downstairs Joe July 28, 2010 at 7:16 AM

    Please note that Downstairs Joe is soon to be A COUPLE TOWNS OVER JOE…. hhahaha

  4. aero July 27, 2010 at 8:01 AM

    The trades may not be going well for the Yankees, but they still can afford any free agent that becomes available.
    My team, the Rays are probably going to lose Carl Crawford to them next year so I have a hard time working up any sympathy for the bums.

    Go Rays!

  5. Chris Humpherys July 26, 2010 at 10:53 AM

    Speaking of Angels pitchers.

    Lackey is 9-5 with a 4.36 ERA. Not sure that’s exactly worth the investment.

    They might as well have signed Scott Erickson.

  6. Upstairs Marnie July 26, 2010 at 5:24 AM

    The Yankees were so sure they were getting Lee he was set to start the night they expected the trade to go thru. Oops!

Comments are closed.